Three South Dakota counties will vote on returning to manual voting tabulation

Voters in at least three rural South Dakota counties will decide Tuesday whether to resume counting ballots by hand. These are the latest communities across the country to consider abandoning machine tabulations based on baseless conspiracy theories stemming from the 2020 presidential election.

The three counties, each with fewer than 6,000 residents, would be among the first in the U.S. to require old-fashioned manual counts, which were long ago replaced by vote tabulations in most of the country.

A number of other states and local governments have considered banning machine counting since the 2020 election, but most of these efforts have focused on the cost, the time it takes to count manually, and the difficulty of hiring more staff to to do this.

'ELECTION INTERFERENCE' CLAIMS MUDDY BATTLEGROUND STATE POLITICS AMID COMPETITIVE MATCHES

Experts say manual counting of votes is less accurate than machine counting.

Supporters of the South Dakota move are undeterred by such concerns.

“We believe that a decentralized approach to elections is much more secure and transparent, and that citizens should have control over their elections,” said Jessica Pollema, president of SD Canvassing, a citizens' group that supports the change.

As elsewhere, the push for hand counting in South Dakota has its roots in false claims made by former President Donald Trump and his allies after the 2020 presidential election, claiming widespread voter fraud and spreading conspiracy theories that voting machines were being manipulated to sway the election. to steal. There is no evidence to support such claims, but they are embedded in many places that voted heavily for Trump.

South Dakota's citizen initiatives to ban tabulating machines will appear during Tuesday's primaries in Gregory, Haakon and Tripp counties. Similar petition efforts for votes on future measures are underway in more than 40 other counties in the conservative state, Pollema said. At least four provinces have rejected attempts to force hand counting.

Previously, the Fall River County Commission voted in February to hand count ballots for the June election, and Tripp County counted ballots by hand for the 2022 general election.

From left to right, Jessica Pollema speaks at the Military Heritage Alliance in Sioux Falls, SD on October 19, 2023. She is the co-founder of South Dakota Canvassing and a leading advocate for getting rid of machines in favor of hand-counting ballots in South Africa. Dakota. (Stu Whitney/South Dakota News Watch via AP)

If the measure passes Tuesday, Gregory County Auditor Julie Bartling said the county will have to increase the number of districts to reduce the burden of hand counting. That will force the country to buy more voting aids for disabled voters. The county will also be faced with the difficult task of hiring more election staff.

Bartling, who organizes the province's elections, is against the initiative and said she has “complete confidence in the automated tabulation systems.”

Todd and Tripp County Auditor Barb DeSersa said they also oppose efforts to require the manual counting of all ballots because the process is not as accurate. She said the 2022 hand count left election workers exhausted.

“I know that those who did it last time didn't want anything to do with it this time, so I think if they do it once or twice, they will get tired of it and it will be harder to find people who will want to volunteer for that,” DeSersa said.

DeSersa's office estimated it would cost $17,000 to $25,000 to count Tripp County elections by hand, compared to about $19,000 to $21,000 using tabulation. Haakon County Auditor Stacy Pinney said she initially estimated hand counting would cost between $750 and $4,500, but “generally, election costs are difficult to determine at this time.”

According to a Haakon County prosecutor's analysis, two election workers using a tabulator would take three to four hours to count all the ballots. It would take 15 to 20 election workers between five and 15 hours to do a hand count, depending on the number of contested races.

According to a national report, the three provinces together have 7,725 active registered voters.

Republican state Rep. Rocky Blare, who lives in Tripp County, said he will vote against the measure.

“They can't prove to me that there were any issues that I think affected our elections in South Dakota,” Blare said.

Secretary of State Monae Johnson, a Republican, expressed confidence in tabulating machines, noting that they have been used for years. In a statement, she pointed to “safeguards built in throughout the process and the post-election audit of the machines after the primaries and general elections to ensure they are working properly.”

The June election will be the first with a post-election audit, a process included in a 2023 state law. It involves hand counting all votes in two races from 5% of precincts in each county to ensure that the machine table is accurate. Johnson's office said there was no evidence of widespread problems in 2020 or 2022. One person voted twice, she said, and was caught.

After repeated attacks on machine counting of ballots in the 2020 presidential election, Dominion Voting Systems reached a $787 million settlement last year in a defamation lawsuit against Fox News over false claims the network repeatedly aired. The judge in that case ruled that it was “CRYSTAL clear” that none of the claims about Dominion's machines were true, and testimony showed that many Fox hosts quietly doubted the claims their network broadcast.

Since 2020, only a few provinces have made the switch to manual counting. In California, officials in Shasta County voted to abolish their ballots, but state lawmakers later limited hand counting to limited circumstances. Officials in Arizona's Mohave County rejected a proposal to distribute the ballots in 2023, citing the $1.1 million cost.

David Levine, a former local elections official in Idaho and now a senior fellow at the Alliance for Securing Democracy, said research has shown that counting large numbers of ballots by hand is more expensive, less accurate and more time-consuming than machine tabulation.

“If you listen to conspiracy theorists and election skeptics across the US, one of the reasons the 2020 election was illegitimate is because of an algorithm. If you take computers out of the voting process, you will have more secure elections,” Levine said. said. “The only problem: it's not true.”

While some areas count ballots by hand, especially in the Northeast, this is typically done in places with a small number of registered voters. Hand counts are common during post-election testing to ensure machines are counting ballots correctly, but only a small portion of ballots are checked manually.

Election experts say it's unrealistic to think that workers in large jurisdictions, with tens or hundreds of thousands of voters, could count all their ballots by hand and report the results quickly, especially because ballots often include multiple races.

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP

“The problem is that humans aren't very good at big, tedious, repetitive tasks like counting ballots, and computers are,” Levine said. “Those who believe otherwise are either unaware of this reality or choose to ignore it.”

Related Posts

The White House is praising Biden's new immigration policy toward undocumented spouses of U.S. citizens

The White House is praising Biden’s new immigration policy toward undocumented spouses of U.S. citizens, With less than five months to go the general electionsPresident Biden announced sweeping federal action…

Texas doctor charged with obtaining confidential patient information about transgender care

A Texas doctor who calls himself a whistleblower on transgender care for minors is accused of illegally obtaining private information about patients at the nation's largest children's hospital who were…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You Missed

S&P 500 futures are rising as Wall Street hopes Nvidia remains the leading market

  • June 20, 2024
S&P 500 futures are rising as Wall Street hopes Nvidia remains the leading market

The retro kick-off tactic that is proving popular (and effective) at Euro 2024

  • June 20, 2024
The retro kick-off tactic that is proving popular (and effective) at Euro 2024

Demand for mortgages is leveling off, even as interest rates reach their lowest level since March

  • June 20, 2024
Demand for mortgages is leveling off, even as interest rates reach their lowest level since March

At least one in four residential yards in the U.S. exceeds the new EPA guideline for lead levels in soil

  • June 20, 2024
At least one in four residential yards in the U.S. exceeds the new EPA guideline for lead levels in soil

General Catalyst makes India push with Venture Highway merger

  • June 20, 2024
General Catalyst makes India push with Venture Highway merger

Shares of Guzman y Gomez are surging more than 39% in their trading debut

  • June 20, 2024
Shares of Guzman y Gomez are surging more than 39% in their trading debut

Two climate activists arrested after spraying orange paint on Stonehenge: NPR

  • June 20, 2024
Two climate activists arrested after spraying orange paint on Stonehenge: NPR

Paradromics wants to make brain implants a reality before the end of this decade

  • June 20, 2024
Paradromics wants to make brain implants a reality before the end of this decade

Golden Goose postpones the Milan IPO due to the political unrest in Europe

  • June 20, 2024
Golden Goose postpones the Milan IPO due to the political unrest in Europe

Lydia Jacoby misses out on Tokyo Olympic gold in Paris after surprise: 'It hasn't fully sunk in yet'

  • June 20, 2024
Lydia Jacoby misses out on Tokyo Olympic gold in Paris after surprise: 'It hasn't fully sunk in yet'

Hours of power outages affect millions of people in Ecuador after transmission line failure

  • June 20, 2024
Hours of power outages affect millions of people in Ecuador after transmission line failure